GG Katie's Famous Spaghetti Sauce Recipe
In 1960, when your Grandmother Coco was two years old and your Great Aunt Julie was a newborn, we lived in Holyoke, Massachusetts for two years. Holyoke at that time was a mixture of Polish, Irish, and Italian cultures, a very Catholic community, and steeped in US history. The Polish foods--the perogis and kielbasa-- along with the standard New England Boiled Dinner and corn chowder, not to mention the Irish brisket, were all brand new tastes for this Texas and Louisiana young mother, and while I lamented the fact that I couldn't find any chili powder or tortillas or filet gumbo, I loved all these new tastes. There is, of course, nothing like a New England pizza or a cheesecake, and I haven't tasted their equal since I left New England.
When we returned to Texas, I brought those tastes back with me. I never could master Polish cooking, but I made the boiled dinner and corn chowder as the girls were growing up. Year by year, those meals fell by the wayside, giving way to our traditional Southern, Cajun, and Tex-Mex fare.
But there is one recipe I brought back with me that has stayed in the family ever since and has been passed down to sisters and children and nieces and their children. And now it comes to you. I got the recipe from a friend, who claimed she got it from an old Italian woman, and I have every reason to believe her.
I have to say that, even though I'm talking about bringing the recipe back with me, it's important to know that I never wrote anything down. I just learned the sauce recipe by heart, and in later years, I wrote it down for your grandmother and great aunt. They have copies of it somewhere, so you need to know that I'm pretty sure no two copies are alike, but they'll all give you the same thick, rich sauce and plenty of it.
I also have to say that I'm not much of a cook, so it's really funny that I that this recipe made me famous in our family, and I will always cook it when we gather.
Famous Spaghetti
1 or 2 yellow onions, finely chopped
3 or 4 green and red bell peppers, finely chopped
about 4 garlic cloves, minced
1 box mushrooms (just plain old mushrooms; this recipe is before the time we had so many choices)
Olive oil (Yes, I was using that long before we understood the health benefits)
This is how you start:
Set aside about 1/2 cup of your onions and peppers to mix in the meatballs. In a large iron skillet, using the olive oil, brown the onions and peppers, then add the mushrooms, and finally the garlic, being careful that it doesn't burn. When the onions and garlic are translucent and the mushrooms and peppers are limber, instead of stiff, transfer the mixture to a large pot, about a 4 quart pot or more. Put your burner on low heat.
Then add an assortment of tomato products.
1 can tomato paste (a must! mix it with water before adding_
2 large cans tomato sauce
2 large cans stewed tomatoes
2 cans whole tomatoes
1-2 cups water
Stir everything together and keep your burner on low.
Add spices and condiments. A sprinking of:
red wine
sugar
Parmesan cheese, grated
oregano
basil leaves
assorted Italian seasoning
salt
Note:
your sauce will cook on low for about 3 hours. During that time, you
should stir the mixture and add seasoning about every 30-45 minutes.
You need to taste the sauce before and after you add stuff.
If you want meatballs:
1 pound premium ground meat
1 pound Italian sausage
egg
bread crumbs
Parmesan cheese
onions and peppers that you set aside
Mix
all of that together into one squishy form; using your hands is the
best way to get everything mixed together evenly, so be sure to wash
them before and especially after.
Using that same iron skillet, and
with the heat turned on low, with a little olive oil in the skillet,
form your meatballs and place in the pan. Don't make them too large or
they'll fall apart. You will need to turn them about 4 times, making
sure they are mostly browned.
Note: You are not cooking the meatballs; you're only browning them so that they will stay together when you add them to the sauce. They will be thoroughly cooked during the hours that the sauce is simmering.
With tongs, gently place the meatballs in the sauce, add more of the condiments, and let the sauce simmer. You have plenty of time to wash up all the dishes and utensils you used, set the table, etc., while the sauce is simmering.
When it's close to time to eat, cook the spaghetti of your choice according to directions. Then people can first put the spaghetti on their plates, then the sauce, then a sprinkling of Parmesan. I like to serve with crusty bread, red wine, and a salad that I learned about on the Amalfi Coast: arugula, sliced cherry tomatoes, toasted pine nuts, shaved Parmesan, and a balsamic dressing.
I've tried to remember everything, but be sure to ask Coco to take a look when you begin making the sauce.
![]() | ||||
| GG Katie, Mother's Day 2023 |
Love,
GG Katie


